The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe > Suggestions Archive

Interview Suggestion: Steve Gibson

<< < (2/2)

Terrorskull:
I was actually going to post or send an email to suggest this myself.  Glad I checked the forums first and found there was already a topic.  I would like to hear more on this topic on the show.  Due to lots of misinformation online and by store employees I find it hard to sort out what sort of supplements really are required/beneficial for everyone or for those of us who do workout with weight training and cardio to really get a maximum benefit.  Steve Gibson, on the other hand, I know is a smart guy who normally goes through lots of technical information and sounds like he did a lot of research on this, so I think it is worth taking a look at what he has said at least.  I hope that we can at least hear a discussion on this topic if not an interview.

PaulJ:
I'd like to add another vote to this thread. Even if you don't get Steve Gibson on the show, it would be useful to discuss his findings and conclusions.

It might also be instructive to hear the panel's views on his method of research. His one-off podcast, The Vitamin D Story, was an entirely amateur effort by someone who describes himself as a "health hobbyist". He does not appear to be susceptible to pseudo-scientific nonsense.

Bear in mind that Steve Gibson commands an enormous amount of well-deserved respect in his own area of expertise (computer security). His podcast has a huge following, so if his arguments and conclusions about vitamin D are in any way flawed I believe he would consider it a useful service to his listeners if any such flaws were identified (I'm pretty sure he would correct them in a follow-up).

moj:
Anther fan of security now and Steve could do a nice tie in to internet security and about being "skeptical" of things on line. Leo regularly has Brian Brushwood and Dr. Kiki on TWIT. I've even heard Leo use his audible spot to plug Christopher Hitchens book "god in not great". While I don't think either are active in the skeptical community there is over lap and think it could make for a good show.

Black_Magic:
It would definitely be an interesting interview! However, if you cannot, or do not want to interview him, PLEASE do a segment on this Vit D mumbo jumbo!

I love me some Steven Gibson, but when he dedicated a podcast to Vit D I thought to myself "This isn't going to end well", but to be honest... I have no idea if it ended well :-\

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page