WHO pronounced her incurable?
Her doctors at Johns Hopkins and Inova Fairfax. They also told her she suffered from an adverse reaction from the seasonal flu vaccine. After it was declared dystonia, the symptoms are considered irreversible.
A doctor also filed a VAERS report.
All of that was checked out by various news agencies.
FX, I understand your not wanting to just not just ignore her case outright, but...
Until the doctors who told her a) it was dystonia and b) she got it from the flu shot actually provide some sort of explanation, mechanism, or even theory about how this could happen, the entire thing is just a huge
post hoc ergo propter hoc. I realize that we sometimes do come to a conclusion of causation without a mechanism, but not when there is only a very, very small number of examinable correlations.
Also, there are two further problems with saying the vaccine caused this, being a) there is quite a bit of controversy if the disease the woman had was actually dystonia (in my opinion all signs point to this NOT being the case at the moment), and b) she also caught the flu after receiving the shot, and thus the flu itself could, based on the same logic, just as easily be considered the cause of whatever disease it is she had.
The point being, yes, it is in theory POSSIBLE that this woman got dystonia from the flu shot, and then the disease (which as you said is considered incurable) was cured within a week or so by a doctor known to use very questionable treatments (why isn't he curing everybody's dystonia if this works?). But, there is absolutely no reason at present to consider this more likely than any alternative, including that she did or did not have dystonia, that it was caused by the flu shot, the flu itself, or a number of other factors, that it may or may not have been a psychogenic 'disorder', or a large number of other possibilities. In my opinion the fact that she has been 'cured' of a hitherto incurable disease in the time frame of a week puts the likelihood of that scenario very low of the scale of probability compared to other scenarios.
