Surely Muslims can use Dawkins' many screeds against Christianity to denigrate that religion as well. Does that make him a Christian hating Christian atheist?
The point that this rabbi is making is that dawkins screed on christianity is derived from actually connecting the negitive aspects of christian scripture to facets of christian culture
Whereas his screed on the old testament is derived from outdated antisemitic ideas of how jewish scripture connects to jewish culture.
I've never seen where Dawkins has a particular issue with Jewish people, just the religion itself.
And the rabbi isn't calling Dawkins an antisemite - hes saying that his synopsis of the torah is derived from antisemitism
In a nutshell: don't try to clothe your anti-atheist bigotry in the rhetoric of tolerance, thanks.
You're right, you did not see the point.
That both the atheist and the antisemite are using the same tool - but for different purposes.
Atheists dont exist in a vacuum.
My larger point is that the arguments WE use against faith both come from (loosely), and are co-opted by bigots.